There’s nothing quite like a rack of pork ribs sizzling on the grill to bring people together. As a self-proclaimed grilling nerd (and a late-30’s dad who’s grilled more ribs than I can count), I often get asked about the baby back vs St Louis ribs debate. Just the other night, we had friends over for a backyard BBQ, and of course the rib talk started: “Which ribs are better, baby back or St. Louis style?” My neighbor swears by baby backs for their tenderness, while I’ve got a soft spot for the rich flavor of St. Louis ribs. In this post, I’ll break down the differences in cut, flavor, tenderness, size, fat content, cooking times, and price – all in a friendly, dad-to-dad tone. By the end, you’ll feel like we just chatted it up over a cold beer, and you’ll know exactly which rib cut is right for your next cookout.
Before we dive in, let me give you a quick snapshot of how these two popular pork rib types stack up:
- Cut & Size: Baby back ribs (aka loin back ribs) come from the upper part of the pig’s ribcage, near the spine. They’re shorter and curved. St. Louis ribs come from further down the ribcage (they’re trimmed spare ribs), so they’re larger, flatter, and form a neat rectangular rack.
- Meat & Fat: Baby backs are leaner with meat on top of the bones (plus a bit on the underside). St. Louis ribs have more meat between the bones and a higher fat content marbled throughout. More fat = more flavor.
- Flavor: Baby back rib meat is mild and tender; it’s close to the pork loin, so it can be a bit less flavorful on its own but picks up rubs and sauces nicely. St. Louis ribs boast a deeper “porky” flavor thanks to that extra fat and connective tissue.
- Tenderness: Baby backs are naturally tender – they’re literally cut from near the tenderloin. St. Louis ribs are a bit tougher raw, but cook them low and slow and they’ll get just as tender, falling off the bone when done right.
- Cooking Time: Because they’re smaller, baby back ribs generally cook faster (think about 4-5 hours in a smoker or a shorter time on a hot grill). St. Louis ribs need a little longer (maybe 5-6 hours smoking) to get perfectly tender, since they start out bigger and fattier.
- Price: Baby back ribs usually cost a bit more per pound than St. Louis cut ribs. They’re in high demand (thanks in part to that famous restaurant jingle – you know the one!), and you get fewer racks per pig. St. Louis ribs (being trimmed spare ribs) are often a better bang for your buck if you’re feeding a crowd.
Now that you have the overview, let’s get into the fun details – with a few personal rib anecdotes along the way!
Cut and Size: Where Do the Ribs Come From?
When we talk about baby back vs. St. Louis ribs, the first big difference is the cut and size. Both of these are pork ribs (we’re not talking beef ribs here), but they come from different sections of the pig’s rib cage.
Baby back ribs (sometimes just called back ribs or loin back ribs) are taken from the upper part of the ribcage, up near the spine, right below the loin muscle. That’s actually why they’re called “back” ribs – because they’re up toward the back of the pig. And no, “baby” back ribs don’t come from baby pigs! The “baby” term just means these ribs are smaller in size compared to spare ribs. Each rack of baby backs is relatively short (usually 1.5 to 2 pounds in weight and about 10–13 ribs per rack). The bones in baby back racks have a gentle curve to them. You’ll notice one end of a baby back rib is a bit thicker and then it tapers down toward the other end; that’s the nature of where it’s cut from near the spine. Despite being smaller, baby backs often have a decent amount of meat on top of the bones (since butchers sometimes leave a little loin meat attached). I remember the first time I grilled baby backs for my in-laws – my father-in-law commented on how the bones were smaller and easy to handle, which made him feel fancy just nibbling on them!
St. Louis style ribs, on the other hand, come from the lower part of the ribcage, closer to the belly. In butcher terms, a St. Louis rib is basically a trimmed spare rib. Spare ribs are the big ribs cut from the whole side of the pig (including some cartilage and the breastbone area). When you take a slab of spare ribs and trim off the rib tips (the cartilage-laden piece at the bottom) and the brisket bone, you get a neat, rectangular rack called St. Louis cut ribs. This cut got its name because it was popularized by butchers in St. Louis who standardized that nice squared-off shape. A rack of St. Louis ribs is typically larger – about 2.5 to 3 pounds with 10–13 ribs as well (the same bones as spare ribs, just trimmed). These ribs are flatter and straighter than baby backs (no big curvature in the bones), which means they lay nicely on the grill. They also look pretty uniform – a full St. Louis rack is a beautiful rectangle of meaty ribs that fills up the plate (or the smoker). In terms of size, my buddy Dave loves when I cook St. Louis ribs because they’re bigger; he calls them “man-sized ribs” as a joke. They do satisfy that caveman instinct of holding a hefty rib with a good chunk of meat on it!
Summary of the cut: Think of the pig’s ribcage as two sections: the baby backs up top near the spine (small, curved, tender ribs from near the loin), and the spares down low near the belly (bigger, flatter ribs). St. Louis ribs are simply the spares trimmed up to remove the gristly bits, leaving only the best part of the spare rib. So, if you get a whole spare rib slab, you can actually cut your own St. Louis ribs (and have some rib tips as a snack on the side). I’ve done this a few times – trimming spare ribs is easier than it sounds. We even pulled up a YouTube video to guide us the first time.
If you’re curious about how it’s done, check out this helpful video on trimming spare ribs into St. Louis style ribs:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PvD29IVBt5A
It shows the simple two cuts needed to get that perfect rectangular rack.
Also, whether you’re cooking baby backs or St. Louis ribs, here’s one of my baby back rib tips (and it applies to St. Louis ribs too): Always remove the membrane on the back of the ribs. This is a thin, silvery skin on the bone side of each rack. Peeling that off will make your ribs more tender and let your seasonings penetrate better. It’s a small prep step that makes a big difference (I learned that trick from a seasoned BBQ friend years ago, and it’s now a must-do in my kitchen).
Flavor and Fat Content: Tasty Differences
Next up, let’s talk flavor. Both baby back and St. Louis ribs are pork (obviously), so they share that delicious savory pork taste we all love. But there are some subtle differences in flavor and definitely differences in fat content between the two cuts.
Baby back ribs are cut from up near the loin, which is a lean part of the pig. That means baby back racks are generally leaner overall. The meat on baby backs tends to have less fat marbling running through it compared to St. Louis ribs. Flavor-wise, I’d describe baby back rib meat as mild, slightly sweet, and very tender. Because there’s usually a bit of loin meat attached on top, you get a taste that’s almost like a cross between pork chops and ribs. It’s a delicate pork flavor. With less fat, baby backs can rely more on your seasoning and smoke for flavor. The good news is, they take on rubs, marinades, and smoke really well. If you slather them in a nice BBQ sauce at the end, you’ll get that classic, crowd-pleasing rib flavor that’s sticky, smoky, and a touch sweet. In fact, at one of my cookouts, we did two racks of baby backs: one with just a dry rub and one with rub + sauce. The consensus was the sauced ones were heavenly (that glaze caramelized nicely on the lean meat). The dry-rubbed rack was super tender and had a pure pork taste that purists appreciated, but some folks found it a tad under-seasoned – which shows baby backs really shine when you jazz them up with spices or sauce.
St. Louis style ribs bring more fat to the party. These ribs come from closer to the belly, so you’ll find a higher fat content and more connective tissue in the meat. Fat equals flavor in the BBQ world. As those St. Louis ribs cook, the fat melts (or “renders out”) and bastes the meat internally, giving it a richer, porkier flavor. I like to say St. Louis ribs have a bit more “oomph” in taste. The meat between those bones is well-marbled, and when you bite into a perfectly cooked St. Louis rib, it’s juicy and has a satisfying savory depth. Some folks claim they can taste a slight difference – maybe St. Louis ribs have a more intense pork flavor and a hint of bacon-like richness (since they’re near the belly). In our neighborhood rib-off, I noticed the St. Louis ribs we made had a slightly smokier flavor too, probably because they needed to smoke longer (more on cook times later). They also developed a beautiful bark on the outside – those extra fats and collagens interact with rubs and smoke to form a tasty crust on the rib surface.
To put it simply: baby backs = tender and lean, subtle flavor, St. Louis = meaty and rich, robust flavor. Neither is “better” across the board; it really depends on what you like. If you prefer a lighter bite or you love drowning ribs in sauce, baby backs might be your go-to. If you’re after a meatier rib with a pronounced pork flavor (and you don’t mind a bit of extra fat), St. Louis ribs will steal your heart. My personal tip: I use a tangy BBQ rub with a bit of brown sugar on St. Louis ribs – the extra fat can handle the sugar caramelization and bold spices. With baby backs, I might go a little easier on the sugar in the rub (since there’s less fat to balance it) or just be sure to mop on sauce at the end for moisture and flavor.
Tenderness and Texture
Let’s talk tenderness – because at the end of the day, we all want ribs that are juicy and pull off the bone easily. Both baby back and St. Louis ribs can be incredibly tender if cooked properly, but there are some differences in their starting tenderness and texture.
Baby back ribs have a reputation for being very tender. That makes sense, considering they come from right alongside the loin (one of the most tender pork cuts). When raw, baby back rib meat has finer grain and less connective tissue to break down. This means that it tenderizes faster during cooking. If you cook baby backs just right, you get that magical “fall-off-the-bone” texture (though BBQ purists will say ribs should have a slight chew, not completely fall off – but that’s personal preference). The meat on a baby back rib, once cooked, is typically silky and soft, with a nice bite. However – and this is important – because baby backs are leaner, you have to be careful not to overcook them. It’s easy to dry out a baby back rib if you leave it on the heat too long or too high. I’ve made this mistake once: got distracted by a conversation (okay, a couple of beers) and left a rack of baby backs on the grill a bit too long. They went from fall-off-the-bone to kinda dry and chewy. Lesson learned! Now I keep a closer eye on them. One thing I love about baby backs is their texture can be almost “delicate” (as far as ribs go) – the pieces of meat on top of the bone will literally melt in your mouth when done right.
St. Louis ribs start off tougher. If you feel a raw St. Louis rack and a raw baby back rack, the St. Louis one is firmer and less bendy due to more collagen and connective tissue. But given time, St. Louis ribs can become just as tender as baby backs – you just have to cook them long enough for all that fat and collagen to break down. When you do, oh boy, the texture is amazing: moist, succulent meat that still has a good substance to it (thanks to that intramuscular fat). I find that properly cooked St. Louis rib meat has a little more “bite” or substance than baby backs, meaning it’s not mushy, it’s tender-but-firm. Personally, I like that – it’s satisfying to bite into. Some of my friends actually prefer St. Louis ribs for that reason; they don’t want the meat completely falling off the bone, they like a bit of chew that says “this is a hearty piece of meat.” With St. Louis ribs, the extra fat keeps things juicy, so they’re a bit more forgiving if you cook them a tad longer. In fact, I often cook St. Louis racks until the meat almost starts to shred when you bite, and the bone comes clean – that’s perfect. You might notice a slight difference in texture of the meat fibers: baby back meat, being lean, is a touch finer; St. Louis meat, with more fat, feels a bit silkier and gelatinous (in a good way) when hot.
In summary, baby backs tend to get tender faster and feel a bit softer, while St. Louis ribs need more time but reward you with an equally tender result that’s extra juicy. If you lined up one of each cooked perfectly, you’d find both plenty tender – but the baby back might feel a bit leaner and the St. Louis a bit moister. Around my house, the kids actually prefer baby backs because the meat is softer and the ribs are smaller (less intimidating to eat). The adults often gravitate to the St. Louis racks for that meaty, melt-in-your-mouth goodness after a long smoke. Either way, tenderness is ultimately about cooking technique, which leads us to…
Cooking Times and Techniques
Cooking these two types of ribs is more similar than different, with a few key tweaks. Whether you’re smoking ribs low and slow, or grilling over indirect heat, the main difference will be how long you cook baby back vs. St. Louis ribs and a bit of technique adjustment due to size.
Because baby back ribs are smaller and leaner, they generally cook through faster. On a traditional smoker at ~225°F, baby backs might take around 4 to 5 hours to reach that perfect tenderness. There’s a popular method called “2-2-1” for baby backs: ~2 hours unwrapped in the smoker, 2 hours wrapped in foil (with maybe a splash of juice or butter inside), then a final 1 hour unwrapped to firm up and sauce. I’ve used that with good results – the foil wrap helps keep them moist since baby backs can dry out. If I’m grilling baby backs on my charcoal grill, I set up two heat zones (hot coals on one side, ribs on the other side – a technique called indirect grilling). I can usually get baby backs done in about 2.5 to 3 hours on the grill at a slightly higher temp (~300°F), basting occasionally. They cook relatively quick; I sometimes toss wood chips on the coals to add a smoky touch, since they won’t be in there as long as St. Louis racks.
St. Louis ribs being larger and fattier, I give them more time. In the smoker at 225°F, you’re looking at roughly 5 to 6 hours. A common approach is the “3-2-1” method for spare ribs (St. Louis falls under this since it’s basically spare ribs without tips): 3 hours unwrapped smoke, 2 hours wrapped, 1 hour unwrapped with sauce to finish. That extra hour (compared to baby backs) really helps break down the tougher meat. I’ve definitely noticed that when I try to rush St. Louis ribs, they come out a bit tough near the bone. Patience pays off! On the grill, I also cook them indirectly, but maybe at a slightly lower temp or just longer – could be about 3.5 to 4 hours at ~300°F. The trick with St. Louis ribs is to allow that fat to render slowly. The reward is ribs that are moist and flavorful. One time, I attempted St. Louis ribs hot-and-fast (around 350°F direct heat) – bad idea! They charred too quickly and the fat caused flare-ups. Lesson: low-and-slow is the way to go, especially for St. Louis style.
Preparation for both types is essentially the same: remove membrane, season generously, and cook with indirect heat. Both cuts love smoke, so using a smoker or adding wood chunks to your grill will enhance flavor. I don’t find that one cut needs radically different spices than the other – any good rib rub (salt, pepper, paprika, maybe some brown sugar and garlic/onion powder) will do wonders on both baby backs and St. Louis. Just remember, because St. Louis have more fat, they can handle sugary rubs and lots of sauce without losing their pork flavor. Baby backs, being leaner, might shine with a slightly lighter touch on strong seasonings so their natural flavor isn’t masked. But hey, at the end of the day, season to your liking!
If you’re new to rib grilling, watching a pro in action can help. I’d recommend checking out a YouTube video like this one, where a BBQ expert cooks and compares both styles of ribs side by side:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XdoVv-Rn238
It walks through trimming, seasoning, and cooking times for baby back vs. St. Louis ribs, with a nice little taste test at the end. When I was learning, seeing someone else manage the timing difference really helped me nail my own rib technique.
A quick note: You can absolutely cook baby back and St. Louis ribs together on the same grill/smoker (I do this all the time when I have a big group and I’m making both kinds). Just be prepared to pull the baby backs off sooner and let the St. Louis racks continue cooking. I usually start the St. Louis ribs about 45 minutes to an hour before the baby backs, so they finish around the same time. That way, everything is hot and ready to serve together.
Types of Grills for Cooking Ribs (and Why It Matters)
You might be wondering if you need a special type of grill or smoker to cook ribs like a champ. The good news is, you can cook great ribs on almost any kind of grill – as long as you can maintain a consistent heat and use indirect cooking. I’ve personally made ribs on a charcoal kettle grill, a gas grill, and a pellet smoker, and each can yield delicious results with a bit of know-how. Here’s a quick rundown of grill types (and where you might consider an upgrade or two):
- Charcoal Grills: A classic Weber charcoal grill can cook amazing ribs. Set it up for indirect heat (coals on one side, ribs on the other), toss in some wood chunks for smoke, and you’re in business. Charcoal and wood give ribs that authentic smoky flavor. Kettle grills and ceramic kamado grills are fantastic for this method (INTERNAL LINK HERE). Just mind your temperature – use the vents to control heat. I’ve had some of my best rib cooks on a simple charcoal grill on a lazy Sunday afternoon.
- Gas Grills: Yes, you can do ribs on a gas grill! The key is indirect heat as well – usually by turning one burner off and placing the ribs over that section, while the other burners are on low. You’ll want a smoker box or a foil packet of wood chips on the lit burner to get some smoky flavor. Gas grills are super convenient for holding a steady temp (INTERNAL LINK HERE), though they don’t naturally impart smoke. I’ve done baby back ribs on my 3-burner gas grill when I was short on time – kept it around 300°F, indirect, with a little hickory chip packet. They turned out tender and lightly smoky. Just be sure to keep the lid closed to trap heat and smoke.
- Pellet Grills/Smokers: Pellet grills (like Traeger, etc.) are basically set-it-and-forget-it smokers. They feed wood pellets to maintain a steady temperature and produce smoke. If you have one, ribs are one of the best things to make on it. You can dial in 225°F and let them go for hours with minimal babysitting. I joke that using my pellet smoker is almost cheating because it’s so easy – I can focus on making my mop sauce or a side dish while the ribs slowly smoke to perfection. Pellet grills (INTERNAL LINK HERE) are great for both baby backs and St. Louis ribs, especially if you’re into smoking ribs without the fuss of tending a fire.
- Dedicated Smokers (Offset, etc.): If you have an offset smoker or a vertical water smoker, those are obviously rib-making machines too. These require a bit more fire management (keeping the wood or charcoal burning right), but they reward you with deep smoke flavor and bark. An offset smoker is what I use for my “special occasion” rib cooks (like when I really want to impress the neighbors on Fourth of July). No matter what, the principles remain the same: low heat, slow cook, indirect exposure to fire, and some wood smoke.
No matter the grill, always factor in the ability to cook indirectly and control the temperature. If your equipment runs a little hot, you might need to adjust times (especially for baby backs so they don’t dry). Conversely, if it’s a struggle to keep the temp up, you might be looking at longer cooks (especially for St. Louis ribs to get tender).
(INTERNAL LINK HERE) – For more on choosing the right grill or smoker for ribs and BBQ in general, you might want to explore our guide on grill types and BBQ setups (that’s your homework for later!).
Alright, now that we’ve covered the rib basics and how to cook them, let’s tackle some of those burning questions people often have about baby back vs. St. Louis ribs.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What’s the difference between baby back ribs and St. Louis ribs, in a nutshell?
Baby back ribs come from the top of the rib cage (near the spine) and are smaller, leaner, and curved. St. Louis ribs come from the lower rib cage (they’re trimmed spare ribs) and are larger, flatter, and fattier. Baby backs are super tender and a bit lighter on meat, while St. Louis have more meat and a richer flavor due to extra fat. Both are pork and both are delicious – they’re just cut from different sections of the pig.
Are St. Louis ribs the same as spare ribs?
Close – think of St. Louis ribs as trimmed spare ribs. A full spare rib slab includes the rib tips and some cartilage. When a butcher removes the rib tips and squaring off the slab, that trimmed rack is called St. Louis style ribs. So all St. Louis ribs are spare ribs, but not all spare ribs are St. Louis (until they’re trimmed up). The trimming makes St. Louis racks more uniform and easier to eat (no cartilage at the bottom).
Why are they called “baby back” ribs?
Despite the cute name, it’s not because they come from baby pigs! “Baby” back ribs are called that simply because they are shorter and smaller than spare ribs. They come from up near the backbone of the pig – the upper ribs that are attached to the spine. They’re also sometimes just called “back ribs” or “loin back ribs.” The word “baby” is just referring to the smaller size compared to the bigger spare ribs from the belly area.
Why are they called “St. Louis” ribs?
St. Louis ribs got their name from the city of St. Louis, Missouri. In the mid-1900s, St. Louis was a hub for meat packing, and butchers there started trimming spare rib slabs in a particular way (removing the rib tips and brisket bone) to create a more uniform rack. This style of rib cut became popular and eventually got dubbed “St. Louis style.” So it’s essentially a regional butchering style that caught on nationwide. (And nope, it doesn’t mean the ribs are cooked or sauced in a St. Louis-specific way – it’s really about the cut.)
Which is better, baby back or St. Louis ribs?
Ah, the million-dollar question! It honestly comes down to personal preference. Baby back ribs are smaller, leaner, and a tad more tender right off the bat – a lot of people love them for their tenderness and because they’re what you often get at restaurants. St. Louis ribs are bigger, meatier, and pack more flavor (thanks to the fat content). Some BBQ enthusiasts prefer St. Louis because they consider them more flavorful and juicy. In my experience, both can be amazing if cooked right. If I must pick: I’d say baby backs for a quick family dinner (especially if folks prefer leaner meat), and St. Louis ribs when I want to impress with full-on BBQ flavor or feed a larger group. But really, you can’t go wrong with either – I often end up cooking both!
Do baby back ribs cook faster than St. Louis ribs?
Yes, generally they do. Baby backs are smaller and have less fat/connective tissue to break down, so they reach tender doneness quicker. Rough estimate: baby backs might take around 4-5 hours at low & slow temps, whereas St. Louis might take 5-6 hours. On a grill over indirect heat, baby backs might be done in 3 hours vs. 4 hours for St. Louis (depending on temp). Always cook until tender rather than strictly by time, but as a rule, plan a bit more time for St. Louis racks.
How many ribs are in a rack of baby back vs. St. Louis ribs?
Both cuts usually have 10 to 13 ribs per rack. It depends on how the butcher divides them. Baby back racks might sometimes have slightly fewer ribs if the very end ones (toward the loin) are cut off with the loin roast. But typically, a full baby back rack and a full St. Louis rack will each have around a dozen bones give or take. The difference is in the size of each rib: baby back ribs are shorter (maybe 5-6 inches long bones), while St. Louis ribs are longer (maybe 6-7+ inches long bones since spare ribs go further down the side).
What are “rib tips” that get cut off spare ribs?
Rib tips are the small strips of cartilage, meat, and gristle that are trimmed away to turn a spare rib slab into a St. Louis cut. They come from the lower end of the spare ribs (closest to the belly). Rib tips don’t have the neat rib bones in them – it’s more a mix of cartilage and small bits of meat. Some people discard them, but many BBQ lovers actually cook rib tips as a snack! They can be seasoned and smoked just like ribs; they’ll turn out chewy, fatty, and very flavorful. So, rib tips are not “tips for cooking ribs” but literally the tips from the ribs.
Should I remove the membrane on both baby back and St. Louis ribs?
100% yes. Both baby back and St. Louis ribs have that thin, silver-white membrane on the bone side. It’s tough and papery, and it doesn’t break down during cooking. Removing it will make your ribs more tender and let your rub penetrate the meat better. Use a butter knife to scrape up a corner of the membrane, grab it with a paper towel, and pull – it usually comes off in one satisfying sheet (sometimes with a few tries). This is a pro tip that applies to all pork rib types.
Can I substitute one type of rib for the other in recipes?
Absolutely. Any recipe that works for baby back ribs will work for St. Louis ribs, and vice versa – you just need to adjust the cooking time. If a recipe is written for baby backs and you want to use St. Louis ribs, give the ribs a bit longer until they’re tender. If swapping St. Louis for baby backs, you might shorten the cook a little. The flavors and techniques (marinades, rubs, sauces) are interchangeable. Just remember: baby backs = smaller & leaner (less time), St. Louis = larger & fattier (more time). I often use the same dry rub and sauce on both cuts and nobody can tell the difference – except that the pieces of rib on the plate might be bigger or smaller!
Are baby back ribs more expensive than St. Louis ribs? Why?
Usually, yes – baby back ribs tend to cost more per pound. The main reason is demand and yield. Each pig only has a small set of baby back ribs (2 racks per pig, since they come from the loin area), and lots of people want them. They’re popular at restaurants and grocery stores often label them as premium. In contrast, spare ribs (and St. Louis cut) are larger and historically considered a bit less “premium” (though every bit as tasty). So, it’s partly supply and demand. Also, baby backs have less bone and fat weight compared to a spare rib slab, so you’re paying for more edible meat per pound – thus the higher price. In my area, I commonly see baby backs maybe $1 or $2 more per pound than St. Louis. Sometimes it even flips (sales or supply issues), but as a trend baby backs cost more. If you’re on a budget or feeding a big crew, St. Louis ribs can be a more affordable way to get your rib fix without sacrificing flavor.
Which type of ribs has more meat on it?
St. Louis ribs generally have more meat between the bones than baby backs do. They come from a meatier section of the rib cage. Plus, they’re larger racks overall, so total meat per rack is higher. Baby backs have that nice hunk of loin meat on top, but between the bones they have a bit less meat (since the ribs taper towards the spine). If you want the meatiest ribs, a well-trimmed St. Louis rack will usually give you more bites of meat. However, keep in mind a lot of that extra weight in St. Louis ribs is also fat. So while you do get more meat, you also get more fat (which, after rendering, just means juicy meat!). If you pick up a rack and think “wow this feels heavy for its size,” it’s probably a St. Louis cut.
Are baby back ribs healthier than St. Louis ribs?
They can be considered slightly “leaner” or lower in fat, yes. Baby backs have less fat, so calorie-wise and fat-wise, they’re a bit lighter. That said, we’re talking about ribs here – not exactly health food to begin with (especially once we slather on BBQ sauce!). If you are watching fat intake, baby backs might be the better choice. St. Louis ribs have more fat and marbling, which means more calories. But that fat also brings a ton of flavor. My philosophy: when enjoying ribs occasionally, go for what you crave and just balance it out with some veggies or a salad on the side. 😄 In moderation, both kinds of ribs can fit into a hearty barbecue feast.
What’s the best cooking method for ribs – grilling, smoking, or something else?
There’s no single “best” method; it depends on your equipment and taste. Smoking ribs low and slow (at ~225°F) is a traditional favorite – it yields super tender, smoky ribs (amazing for St. Louis racks, especially). Grilling over indirect heat works great too, and is usually faster – you might grill at a bit higher temp (300°F or so) and still get tender ribs in a few hours, with some smokiness if you add wood chips. Some folks even do oven-baked ribs (slow roast then finish on the grill for char) – which can be foolproof for tenderness, though you miss out on smoke flavor from the grill. If you ask me, I prefer using my smoker or charcoal grill for that authentic BBQ result. But I’ve had success with all these methods. As long as you cook them gently and long enough, both baby back and St. Louis ribs can turn out awesome. Pro tip: No matter the method, use a meat thermometer or the “bend test” (pick up the rack with tongs – if it bends and the meat starts to crack on the surface, they’re done) to know when the ribs are ready.
Final Thoughts
By now, you should have a good handle on the whole baby back vs. St. Louis ribs saga. In the end, both cuts have a special place in the BBQ world (and on my grill). If you’re after tender, lean, and quick-cooking ribs, baby backs might be your best friend. If you want meaty, flavorful ribs with a bit more indulgence, St. Louis style is the way to go. Why not try both and decide for yourself? Heck, do what I do – make it a little rib showdown at home. Invite some friends, cook up racks of each, and enjoy the research! The fun part of grilling is the experimentation (and the tasty rewards). No matter which ribs you choose, remember to take your time, enjoy the process, and savor that moment when you take the first bite of smoky, tender pork goodness. Happy grilling, friends – may your racks be ever juicy and your BBQ always bring people together!
Further Reading
Interested in learning even more rib and grilling tips? Here are some great resources to up your grill game (each of these topics is a whole conversation of its own!). Check them out for deeper dives and handy techniques:
- How Long to Grill Ribs for Perfect Tenderness – Master timing for fall-off-the-bone goodness.
- Different Types of Ribs Explained (Beef, Pork, & More) – Get to know all the rib cuts out there.
- How to Tell When Pork Ribs Are Done – Tips for checking rib doneness beyond “time”.
- Best Wood for Smoking Ribs – Explore flavor profiles of hickory, apple, and more.
- How to Reheat Leftover Ribs – Because even day-after ribs should be delicious.
Discover more from Own The Grill
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
