Butcher Paper vs Parchment Paper – What’s the Difference?

Butcher Paper Versus Parchment Paper

This content contains affiliate links.  If you make a purchase after clicking a link on this page, we might receive a commission at no cost to you.

Among the many debates concerning paper, butcher paper and parchment paper are two of the most discussed topics of their usage and their many special properties.

So you are probably wondering exactly what separates the two and where one performs better than the other, aren’t you? Well, you are at the right place to find all the answers you are looking for.

At the end of the day, although both of these items are used in conjunction with food they are quite different from one another. Read on to learn more!

What Is Butcher Paper?

Butcher paper is used by BBQ pit masters to wrap meats before and during cooking. Wrapping large pieces of meat has a few benefits and generally makes the cooking process easier and your BBQ’s flavor better

Butchers paper is a type of treated thin paper used for wrapping meats like brisket. It is usually brown or light pink in color. Pink butcher paper is very popular for barbecues because it is easy to clean up after cooking.

Pink butcher paper is popular among smokers because it keeps moisture inside to ensure your meat remains juicy and tender while cooking. At the same time, pink butcher paper is porous enough to allow smoke through to flavor your food.

Contrast this with aluminum foil – which keeps plenty of moisture inside but doesn’t allow any smoke from your smoker to absorb into your food.

When Should You Use Butcher Paper?

Pink butcher paper is ideal for cooking meats on the BBQ because the heat is low enough to prevent the paper from catching fire.

You shouldn’t try to grill meat wrapped in pink butcher paper, even if you’re using indirect heat – as pink butcher paper can catch fire once temperatures reach about 450ºF.

Use foil on the grill instead if you need to wrap something (grilled corn comes to mind).

Pink butcher paper is appropriate for use on the smoker for just about any type of smoked meat. It’s especially popular for brisket, where it can speed up the cooking process, keep your meat moist, all the while allowing it to develop a beautiful crusty outer bark.

The downside to using pink butcher paper in a smoker is that if you try to save the meat juice for a sauce or demi glace, your meat won’t be as juicy as one made with other products.

Great for Smoking BBQ
Meat Hugger - Pink Butcher Paper Dispenser Box
  • Large roll with easy tear box dispenser
  • Refill rolls widely available
Check Price on Amazon

What Is Parchment Paper?

Parchment paper is made using wood pulp, water, and other chemicals. This type of paper is very strong, durable, and absorbent. It is heat resistant and doesn’t melt when heated.

It is often used for baking. Some people use it for arts and crafts. Re-use is possible. 

This material is waterproof. It is also greasy resistant. It can be used for decoration as well. When the question comes to whether parchment paper can be used for freezing, the answer would be a strict no.

The lack of a coating on parchment paper makes it unsuitable to be used to freeze food (for that you should use freezer paper). They are unable to lock in moisture to keep meat fresh.

When Should You Use Parchment Paper?

Parchment paper is used most often for lining baking sheets and cake pans. Using the bottom of the pan to help guide the shape of the paper, draw a circle on the paper and cut out around it.

Fold the paper over the edge of the pan and press down firmly to get rid of any air pockets, then trim off the excess. 

Use parchment paper to sift dry ingredients, pour liquids into containers, and separate layers of sticky treats. Put a sheet of parchment paper between each layer of candy or cookie dough to prevent them from sticking together.

A piping cornet for icing is made out of parchment paper. To create a piping cornet for icing, you need parchment paper, a knife, and melted chocolate or icing.

You can use parchment paper to make a piping cornet for ice cream. Use a knife to cut the parchment paper into strips. 

Then, melt the chocolate or icing in a microwave oven. Dip the end of the strip of parchment paper into the melted chocolate or icing. Let the chocolate harden.

Draw designs on the hardened chocolate using a toothpick. Cut the design off the toothpick. Repeat this process until you’ve created your desired design.

Wrapping Your Meats

Wrapping your meats in butcher paper before smoking them makes sure they stay moist and tender. Proponents of the Texas crutch say that it helps retain moisture as it cooks, making the cooking time easier to predict. 

It can also help make the cooking times easier. Briskets and butts take longer to cook since the evaporation slows down the process.

Wrapping them helps speed up the process by keeping the heat inside the meat instead of letting it escape. Wrappers help protect your barbecue from direct heat. 

You won’t get any burnt spots on the bark because of wrappers. Dry meat doesn’t matter when you’re using them

Butcher Paper vs Parchment Paper – Availability

Availability

Butcher paper can be found in most grocery stores. Some places may carry parchment paper, but you’re probably better off looking elsewhere. You can also buy it online. 

Parchment paper is better than butcher paper because it doesn’t absorb the juices from your cuts of meat. It also allows you to re-use the juices in sauces or gravies. Silicone-treated parchment paper retains the juices better than untreated parchment paper.

When smoking briskets or pork shoulders, be sure to use a slow cooker that doesn’t get too hot. Briskets and pork shoulders need to cook slowly to avoid burning them.

Parchment paper is a versatile tool for covering work areas. It works great for lining baking sheets and cake pans, and it also covers work areas.

Butcher paper is more useful for protecting your work area because it is less likely to contaminate anything.

Butcher vs Parchment – What’s Are The Main Differences?

Paper is made by mixing pulp with chemicals. In the case of butcher paper, these chemicals are sulfide and sodium hydroxide.

These chemicals help make strong paper in density and strength, but in the case of parchment paper, only sulphuric acid is added. Parchment paper is created by soaking the acid in the paper. 

This creates an extra lining and protects the paper from corrosion. Parchment paper is non-stick and can be used for baking, while butcher paper is sticky and can’t be used for baking. Both parchment and butcher paper are made from paper.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will Parchment Paper Burn?

Parchment paper is paper, but it won’t catch on fire with direct flames, nor will it catch fire when exposed to a hot grill or smoker.

However, if you leave your parchment paper in the smoker or grill for more than 15 minutes, it could start a fire. Parchment paper and butcher paper should be used when grilling meats over an open flame. Most grills have open flames and thus need to be protected by these items.

Will Butcher Paper Burn?

Yes, most butcher papers will start to burn around 450ºF. It might even start at lower temperatures if you’re using a cheap brand.

That’s why butcher paper is typically used only on a smoker, were temperatures don’t generally get much higher than 250ºF.

Final Thoughts

Both parchment paper and butcher paper are made up of paper pulp and chemicals. Parchment paper is used to protect meat in an oven while butcher paper is used to wrap or cover items.

They are both used for different purposes. Butcher paper comes in many colors. Parchment paper is only available in white. Butcher paper doesn’t come in some colors like parchment paper.

Parchment paper is not moisture-proof, but butcher paper is. Butcher Paper is used to wrap meat and fish. Parchment Paper is used to line a pan during baking. Wax Paper is used to wrap food to keep them safe from the cold.

Parchment paper and butcher paper are similar, but they differ in important ways. Be aware of what you should look for when you buy parchment paper or butcher paper. So you are always ready for whatever you need the paper for, it may be best to keep both at home. 

After learning the differences between butcher paper and parchment paper, you are now ready to use them in the kitchen or on the grill! Even before you start cooking, they can be used!

Your family and friends will have a good time cooking food for you, no matter what method you use.