Nexgrill vs Weber – Who Makes the Better Grill?

nexgrill vs weber

This content contains affiliate links.  If you make a purchase after clicking a link on this page, we might receive a commission at no cost to you.

We are often asked by grilling fans around the globe what is the best grill on the market – Nexgrill or is it Weber? And as you probably already know, they are both contenders in the grilling world and both have their advantages over the other.

So how do you know which grill is the best for you? By comparing the specs on both and seeing who is offering better components and value. We know that this is a big discussion in the grilling world, so we decided to dig in and get to the bottom of this long quest for the winner.

We will be looking at the size of the cooking area, what kind of heat output is used, how long is the warranty, design, how heavy is it (we all end up moving our BBQ all over the place during prime grilling season), affordability and any additional components that should be highlighted when comparing two top brands like Nexgrill vs Weber.

First, we will introduce you to our top choices for EASY compact grilling with Nexgrill and Weber, showcasing their specs and advantages. Then we will take a closer look at the bigger units that offer 4 or 5 burners, warming stations, and side burners.

The goal in these comparisons is to highlight the benefits of using each brand and determining who they do overall vs on game day. From small intimate dinners to full blow-out parties – we’ve got you covered!

Here’s a little background on both companies, they’ve both been around the block a few times and are well-known manufacturers of some of the best grilling tools in the world. Weber-Stephen Products LLC was a family-owned business until it sold the majority of the company to BDT Capital Partners back in 2010. Whereas Nexgrill Industries, Inc. was built straight out the gate to start manufacturing quality made grills and other heat-related products.

Nexgrill vs Weber – Large Gas Grills

Weber Genesis II E-435 4-Burner Gas Grill

Weber Genesis II E-435 4-Burner Gas Grill
  • 69,000 total BTUs heat output
  • 844 sq. in. cooking surface area
  • Backed by 10 year warranty
Check Price on BBQGuys Check Price on Amazon

If entertaining a lot of family and friends is your specialty, then this powerhouse is definitely in the game! Believe it or not, you can actually cook up to two dozen burgers at once while heating the buns on a warming surface.

Now we know that every day is not a party day and what makes this grill so special is the ability to control how much space you want to heat and use based on the size of your meal.

The Weber Genesis II E-435 is available in both natural gas and propane configurations and can be purchased in the solid stainless steel option or the combination of stainless steel and black casing.

What we liked the most:

  • Infinity Ignition & Huge Cooking Surface
  • 4 High-Performance Burners, Sear Station, And Side Burner (69,000 BTUs Combined)
  • Heats Super-Fast And Can Cook Large Quantities Of Food
  • 10 Year Warranty, 100% Weber Guarantee
  • iGrill 3 Compatible (Notifies You When Food Is Ideally Cooked)
  • Heat Output – 69,000 BTUs Per Hour Combined
  • Cooking Surface – 844 Sq. (Including Tuck-Away Warming Rack)
  • Color – All Stainless Steel OR Offered In Solid Black
  • Warranty – 10 Year

With the large cooking surface and the enclosed storage, you’ll have everything you need to start entertaining your loved ones. The Weber Genesis II S-435 has the ability to cook perfectly grilled food every time with its advanced technology coming from the iGrill 3 – displaying the real-time temperature on your mobile device!

We loved how the sear station was designed to offer intense heat to quickly add those perfect sear marks and how easy the side burner was for heating up soup and sautéing the veggies!

Nexgrill 5-Burner Propane Gas Grill

This grill is made from durable stainless steel and comes with an impressive black front cabinet and a side burner for easy sautéing while simultaneously grilling your main course.

The 5-Burner capacity gives you multiple options while grilling – including warming bread or cooking low-temps foods such as veggies while grilling your meat on higher temps at the same time.

What we liked the most:

  • Total Heat Output From The Five Main Burners = 50,000 BTUs And 12,000 BTU Side Burner
  • Infrared Technology
  • Electric Ignition And Porcelain-Coated Cast Iron Grates
  • Angled Flame Tamers
  • Individual Cooking Elements For Varied Cooking Options
  • Heats Super-Fast And Can Cook Large Quantities Of Food
  • Corrosion-Resistant Material
  • Heat Output – 50,000 BTUs Per Hour
  • Cooking Surface – 480 Sq. (including 159 Sq. Warming Surface)
  • Color – Stainless Steel & Black
  • Warranty – 1 Year

One of the best features of the Nexgrill 5-Burner Grill is that it can easily be the main player in huge family gatherings or parties.

It gives you the ability to cook a dozen burgers or more at one time while heating the buns on the warming rack – not to mention sautéing mushrooms and onions on the side burner. You really can prepare the entire meal on this Nexgrill 5-Burner Unit!

With the budget-friendly price tag, you really can’t go wrong with this grill if you have the space to accommodate it!


Final Decision – Large Grills

Being that these are two of the topmost manufacturers in the grilling industry, we wanted to give you the closest comparison in performance.  The cooking space was virtually double the size on the Weber Genesis II S-435, however; we felt that when it comes to entertaining – you are more likely cooking for 12 to 15 people and both of these grills can handle that capacity.

But okay, if you are into grilling for the masses, then yes, the Weber Genesis II S-435 is going to be the clear winner on that front. We did find that the grease management system was more reliable on the Weber as well, however; they both cleaned up quite easily.

We know that you want to know what the best choice was between the Nexgrill vs Weber, but there are only slight differences between these that really boil down to how much you are willing to spend.

The Weber Genesis II S-435 has delivered in every way possible, but the price is also a bit steep for some people and you will need to decide if the stylish look, technology, and flavoring bars are worth the extra costs.

We also found that the Nexgrill 5-Burner Grill was a great value in comparison to its competitor. It can deliver quality and features that are reliable in producing great tasting food. Don’t underestimate this grill, it can certainly stay on the porch with the big dogs anytime!

Nexgrill vs Weber – 2-Burner Gas Grills

Weber Spirit II E-210 2-Burner Grill

If the look and design of your grill play any part in your decision making, then the Weber Spirit II E-210 will win hands down with its sleek appearance and grease management for super easy cleanup! Not to mention the easy access to the fuel tank and the flavored bars making every meal taste great.

What we liked the most:

  • Electronic Crossover System
  • Heat Output – 26,500 BTUs Per Hour
  • Mounted Thermometer & Fuel Gauge
  • Sleek Open Cart Design With Infinity Ignition
  • Innovative Flavoring Bars
  • Heat Output – 26,500 BTUs Per Hour
  • Cooking Surface – 450 Sq. (including 90 Sq. Warming Surface)
  • Gs4 Grilling System
  • Weight – 103 lbs.
  • Color – Black
  • Warranty – 10 Years

The Weber Spirit II E-210 is a bit more pricey than its competitors, but that’s nothing new. They do deliver on all specs and go above and beyond with their innovative designs. This 2-burner grill is certain to add curb appeal to wherever you put it!

Add the fact that the flavorizer bars are angled perfectly to catch drippings that give you that smoky flavor we all love to taste on our baby back ribs! Don’t worry about any mess because the drippings that aren’t vaporized easily follow the slope design and are glide into the grease management system.

Nexgrill Evolution 2-Burner Propane Gas Grill

If you’re looking for a compact size grill that is easy to use and will fit almost on any size patio, deck, or small backyard, then this grill with infrared technology is a good choice!

Unlike other traditional technologies and conventional grilling methods, the Nexgrill Evolution Gas Grill makes sure that your food doesn’t come in contact with the hot surfaces and prevents your food from getting charred.

What we liked the most:

  • Comfortable Design With Two Stainless Steel Burners
  • Heat Output – 28,000 BTU Per Hour (Corrosion Resistant)
  • 450 Sq. (385 Sq. Cooking Area & 65 Sq. Warming Rack)
  • Electronic Ignition & Built-In Thermometer
  • Folding Sides For Space Saving
  • Heat Output – 28,000 BTUs Per Hour
  • Cooking Surface – 385 Sq. + 65 Sq. Warming Area
  • Gs4 Grilling System
  • Weight – 100.6 lbs.
  • Color – Stainless Steel
  • Warranty – 1 Year From Registration

The Nexgrill Evolution Gas Grill comes with an easy grease management system for simple and fast cleanup. The infrared plates are designed for even cooking of food and with the porcelain cast-iron grates offering high heat retention, you’re sure to get those awesome sear marks!


Final Decision – Small Grills

Since both the Nexgrill Evolution and the Weber Spirit II E-210 are very similar in size, heat output, technology, performance, ease of cleaning, and durability – it will basically come down to what really matters the most to you.

If you have a budget that needs to be maintained, then the Nexgrill Evolution would probably make the most sense. However, if the cost is not a concern then the Weber Spirit II E-210 with its sleek design and fuel monitoring gauge would probably put them at the #1 choice. Don’t forget there is a huge difference in the life of the warranty – if that matters most to you, then there is a clear winner here!

Keep in mind that a 2-burner grill is mainly used when cooking for 2 to 4 people on a regular basis. If you have a larger family or you like to throw parties, then we suggest looking at a 4 or 5-burner size grill because you will be able to cook larger quantities at the same time.

But in all honesty, you can’t go wrong with either one of these beauties, they both deliver great-tasting food with visible sear marks that would make any chef proud!

Performance vs Temperature

The main burners on a gas grill can range from at least 10,000 BTUs up to well over 50,000 BTUs when looking at the commercial lines, so how do you know what is best for you? We generally think that the average household should consider grills between 25,000 BTUs and 50,000 BTUs (unless you are living in a very small or extra-large space).

When considering flame-broiling or searing your meat, then the temperature will play a huge part in your decision-making. Most quality grills will offer a range in temperatures from 200 to 500 degrees, so you can also enjoy the smoked flavor on your salmon or ribs while utilizing the lower temps.

You should also take into consideration that the more BTUs your grill has, the faster it will burn up your fuel – so consider only buying a grill with the estimated amount of BTUs that you are likely to use most often when grilling.

Note: BTU = British Thermal Units (Energy Needed To Raise Temperature)

How Do You Choose Between Propane And Natural Gas?

Both propane and gas grills will achieve the same results in taste, with some pretty big differences between them that are worth mentioning.

Propane gas grills contain more energy than the natural gas option and they will heat up significantly faster – probably the main reason most people prefer propane gas over the genuine alternative. They also allow you the option of using indirect heating and or different levels of temperatures at the same time. Best of all, the quick startup with the simple push of an ignition button.

On the other hand, natural gas will be cheaper than propane – but not as easily accessible. You can go to just about any supermarket and pick up a propane tank for your BBQ. Don’t forget that when choosing natural gas you will need to install the necessary pipes for delivering the natural gas to your grill.

Both are environmentally friendly and provide the same results while cooking. The natural gas option might cost more initially due to the installation process but could save you more money in the long run and the headache that comes with running out of propane right in the middle of cooking.

Final Thoughts on Nexgrill vs Weber

When comparing Nexgrill vs Weber, it’s never an easy decision because both of these manufacturers offer quality, state-of-the-art grills that outrank most of the competition. So when having to choose who is the best, well – we’ve narrowed it down to this:

  • The performance was a toss-up, they both equally perform as expected considering the BTUs. If you want to go by the maximum BTUs, then Weber is the winner.
  • Heating Surface also goes to Weber, but this should be taken lightly since it really depends on how much heated surface you really need. What’s the point in having a huge grill when you mainly cook for 2 to 4 people on a regular basis. Although, nobody is judging you for wanting to be prepared for the big game day!
  • Technology also goes to Weber simply because they have simply outdone themselves with the innovative iGrill 3 – seriously, you can sit on the couch and monitor the temp of your meat on the grill just by looking at your mobile device, now that’s impressive!
  • Value for your money goes to Nexgrill, other than all the extra bells and whistles that the Weber offers – your food will ultimately taste just as good on both the Nexgrill and Weber.
  • Cleanup is easy with the grease management system that both manufacturers utilize on all their grills – including disposable drip trays that can be easily replaced when cleaning no longer makes sense due to the amount of wear.
  • When considering the warranty, Weber is the clear winner with its standard 10-year warranty and 100% guarantee – it doesn’t get much better than that! Things happen, you just never know when you might need to take advantage of a manufacturer’s warranty.

It actually gets personal when choosing Nexgrill vs Weber because the specs and performance are generally in line with each other, it’s the design and the extras that make it more personal.

If you want something that will impress the neighbors, then by all means, definitely go with the Weber – but if you just want a really great-tasting steak, the Nexgrill will satisfy your taste buds just as well.

We gave you all the details, now you decide what will work best for you!