If you click a link on this page, then go on to make a purchase, we might receive a commission – at no extra cost to you.

Weber Pellet Grill Reviews – How Do Weber’s New Pellet Grills Stack Up?

**Important Note – early customer feedback of Weber pellet grills hasn’t been great! Many of the units are running far too hot and customers are having trouble hitting their temperatures.

The below reviews are based on my personal experience, it sounds like I got exposed to two well made units while a few others have been delivered poorly made units.  I’d imagine Weber will straighten this out but for the time being, take this post with a grain of salt.**

 

The turn of the decade has brought us a couple of exciting new pellet grills on the horizon.

One of the best brands in the world of grilling, Weber, is venturing into the world of pellet grills!  They’re releasing their very first pellet grills early in 2020 under their SmokeFire series, which will start off with 2 different pellet grills.

If you haven’t heard of the pellet grill craze, it’s a form of grilling and smoking that run by burning cylindrical wood pellets as the source of fuel.

Over the last few years, this form of grilling has exploded in popularity for a couple of main reasons – but we’ll get into that more a little later.

First, we’ll dive into each of the 2 pellet grills in the series, the Weber SmokeFire EX4 and the Weber SmokeFire EX6.  From there, we’ll go over the SmokeFire series from a high level to highlight the shared features across all Weber pellet grills.

Quick Comparison

Preview
Top Pick
Weber 23510001 SmokeFire EX6 Wood Fired Pellet Grill, Black
Great Choice
Weber 22510001 SmokeFire EX4 Wood Fired Pellet Grill, Black
Cooking Area
1,008 sq in
672 sq in
Temperature Range
200 - 600 Fahrenheit
200 - 600 Fahrenheit
Dimensions
57 x 30 x 46 in
45 x 30 x 46 in
Weight
207 lbs
186 lbs
Power Source
Wood Pellets
Wood Pellets
GS4 Grilling System?
Oversized Hopper?
Prime?
-
Top Pick
Preview
Weber 23510001 SmokeFire EX6 Wood Fired Pellet Grill, Black
Cooking Area
1,008 sq in
Temperature Range
200 - 600 Fahrenheit
Dimensions
57 x 30 x 46 in
Weight
207 lbs
Power Source
Wood Pellets
GS4 Grilling System?
Oversized Hopper?
Prime?
Check Price
Great Choice
Preview
Weber 22510001 SmokeFire EX4 Wood Fired Pellet Grill, Black
Cooking Area
672 sq in
Temperature Range
200 - 600 Fahrenheit
Dimensions
45 x 30 x 46 in
Weight
186 lbs
Power Source
Wood Pellets
GS4 Grilling System?
Oversized Hopper?
Prime?
-
Check Price

Weber Pellet Grill Reviews

Weber SmokeFire EX6 Wood Fired Pellet Grill

My feeling is that after a year or so the Weber 23510001 SmokeFire EX6 will be regarded as one of the best overall pellet grills on the market, period.  It’s a beautiful, versatile, and durable grill that isn’t particularly cheap – but it’s worth every penny in my opinion.

As far as cooking space goes, there’s a whopping 1,008 square inches of cooking space distributed across a main grilling grate and a secondary area near the top of the main chamber.  Its dimensions are 57 x 30 x 46 inches and it weighs 207 pounds – so it’s the kind of grill that will basically be a fixture in your outdoor cooking area.

The EX6 heats incredibly fast and has a wide temperature range between 200 and 600 degrees.  A range that wide allows you to just as easily sear or smoke different types of food, and everything in between.

A bunch of super convenient features are built in to make life easy for the grill master.  You can change and monitor the temperature of your grill and food from a phone app.  A large capacity hopper lets you fill up with over 22 pounds of hoppers at a time so there isn’t a constant need to refill.

Perhaps my favorite feature is the design of the grease management and clean up system.  All grease and ash is funneled away from the flame and into a pan in a removable drawer that couldn’t be easier to clean when it fills up.

Things We Like:

  • Heavy duty, incredibly sturdy design is long lasting and retains heat
  • 1,008 square inches of cooking area is a ton of space to get to work!
  • Powerful engine prevents auger jams and provides reliable, consistent heat
  • Flavorizer bars and Smoke Boost add extra delicious flavor to your food
  • Everything about your grill and food can be managed from the convenience of your phone or the built in LED display
  • Large capacity hopper holds over 22 pounds of pellets at a time
  • 3 year warranty included

Things We Don’t:

  • Nothing at the moment – we’ll watch carefully as customers give feedback over time and update this post with anything we don’t like about Weber pellet grills.

 

Check Price on BBQ Guys  Check Price on Amazon

 

Weber SmokeFire EX4 Wood Fired Pellet Grill

The Weber 22510001 SmokeFire EX4 is an incredibly well designed pellet grill with a sleek, modern, aesthetically pleasing design.

It has 672 square inches of cooking area split between a larger lower grate and a smaller upper rack.  That’s plenty of space to smoke a big brisket, multiple racks of ribs or multiple chickens.  If you’re consistently cooking for your family, it’s more than enough space to comfortably get the job done.

Dimensions wise the EX4 is 45 x 30 x 46 inches – so while I wouldn’t consider it compact per se, it’s definitely small enough that you can fit it into decently tight spaces.  It won’t completely overtake your patio our outdoor kitchen.  A heavy duty porcelain enameled finish is used on most of the grill surface which not only looks good, but has anti-rust and weather-proof properties as well.

Since there’s a lot going on under the hood of a pellet grill, they unfortunately weigh a lot.  This one weighs 186 pounds so that’s a consideration if your dedicated grilling space isn’t easy to access.  Heavy duty caster wheels are built in though to help a little bit with transportation.

We’ll dive deep into the features that are shared across all Weber pellet grills here shortly – but this grill is loaded with everything you need as the pit master and more.

Things We Like:

  • Heavy duty, incredibly sturdy design is long lasting and retains heat
  • Powerful engine prevents auger jams and provides reliable, consistent heat
  • Flavorizer bars and Smoke Boost add extra delicious flavor to your food
  • Everything about your grill and food can be managed from the convenience of your phone or the built in LED display
  • Large capacity hopper holds over 20 pounds of pellets at a time
  • 3 year warranty included

Things We Don’t:

  • Nothing at the moment – we’ll watch carefully as customers give feedback over time and update this post with anything we don’t like about Weber pellet grills.

 

Check Price on BBQ Guys  Check Price on Amazon

 

SmokeFire Series Overview

One of the best things about modern day pellet grills is how well designed and technologically advanced they are.  Everything is set up to make life as simple and easy as possible for you as the griller, and most (if not all) grill functions can be managed from a phone app.

The Weber SmokeFire Series is about as sophisticated as it gets and comes with some pretty exciting features:

Weber Connect

The aesthetic and design of the Weber Connect phone app is simple and clean.  The primary function of the app is to be able to control and monitor the temperature of your grill and of your food as you cook from the convenience of your phone.  It really is an incredibly convenient way to grill.  You can get other tasks done or watch the game while you manage your food.

The app also has some really nice optional features built in that are geared towards beginners.  You can select which type of meat you’re cooking then receive flip and serve notifications, food readiness countdowns, and doneness alerts automatically to your smart phone.  It really helps to take the guesswork out of the equation if you’re cooking a meat you haven’t cooked before!

All of the Weber Connect functionality also comes via an easy to read, weather proof LED display that’s built into the grill.  So if you’re the type who prefers to hang out by the grill and check on your food with your own eyes, you’re able to manage everything from the LED display.

Temperature Range

One of the absolute best things about the pellet grill class in general is versatility when it comes to temperature range.  The Weber SmokeFire Series family of pellet grills is no different, and come equipped with possibly the best temperature range of any brand of pellet grill.

Both of the weber pellet grills have a temperature range of 200 to 600 degrees Fahrenheit.

That temperature range opens up a world of possibilities.  Down near 200-275 degrees is ideal temperature for smoking, and 550-600 means you can sear as well.  It’s incredibly convenient to have the capability to sear, smoke, and anything in between – and to do it well.

Overall Construction

With any grill or smoker, the quality of construction is of the utmost importance.  You need something that will retain heat so that you can achieve consistent results with your food.  A well made grill will also be weather resistant, anti-rusting, and last a long time with proper care.

Weber knocked it out of the park with the design of their pellet grill.  Their porcelain enameled finish is one of the most weather resistant surfaces used on any grill on the market.  Rusting, cracking, and chipped paint are not worries at all here.  It also does a really nice job of retaining heat which ensures even and consistent heat distribution for cooking your food.

Clean Up Features

One of the few gripes I have with pellet grills in general is that broadly speaking, they aren’t the easiest to clean compared to other grills.

Some other brands don’t help things out much with poor design features.  Things like placing a grease pan under the cooking grate that blocks the flame’s direct heat and collects grease and ash.  Or a side mounted grease bucket that is messy and easy to bump into.

Weber pellet grills address a lot of these common issues with a design that’s geared towards making cleanup as easy as possible.

Basically, systems inside the grill direct all ash and grease to a dedicated grease pan.  The grease pan sits in a removable drawer well away from the flame and your food.  All you need to do to remove grease is simply open the drawer, remove the pan, and dispose of the built up ash and grease.

Flavor Boosting

There are actually two features on weber pellet grills that help to enhance the flavor of your food.

The first is unique to the Weber brand and is also featured on their Spirit and Genesis grills.  V shaped “flavorizer bars” serve a couple of functions.  They direct heat across the entire cooking area to help with even heat distribution.  They also get pretty hot when you grill at high heats, so when food drippings fall through the grates and land on the flavorizer bars, the drippings sizzle and vaporize.  The resulting steam rises back up to the food and boosts the flavors you’ll find in your food.

The second feature is unique to the SmokeFire line of pellet grills specifically.  There’s a Smoke Boost setting on the Weber Connect LED display and app.  As the name suggests, selecting this setting at the beginning of your cook will cause the grill to smolder pellets for extra smoke.  If you crave that traditional BBQ smoky flavor – you can add more at the press of a button with Weber pellet grills.

Hopper

The hopper of a pellet grill is a really important piece of tech.  It’s the vessel through which the fuel pellets feed into a fire and heat your food.

Weber’s hoppers are big enough to hold over 20 pounds of pellets – which means you won’t have to constantly refill every time you cook.

It’s also designed with a DC powered “Responsive Incline Drive engine” which was specially designed to help prevent auger jams.  Basically, you’re highly unlikely to run into any hopper or auger issues with any of the Weber pellet grills.

Warranty

I’m a huge advocate for purchasing products that are backed by manufacturer’s warranties.  Not only does it protect you in the unlikely event that you receive a faulty item, it’s a sign of competence and integrity from the brand itself.

Weber is one of the best brands in outdoor cooking.  They back it up with their 3 year warranty for their SmokeFire series pellet grills.

Does Weber Make Wood Pellets?

They do!  At the moment, Weber does sell wood pellets on their website.  As with any pellet grill, you should feel free to use any type of wood pellets made for smoking in a pellet grill with your Weber pellet grill.

Weber Pellet Grill Reviews – Wrap Up

Are you going to be one of the first to own a Weber pellet grill?  If you are, let us know about it!  We want to hear your feedback and which model you chose in the comments section below.

Want to see how these grills stack up against other brands?  Check out our comparison of the Weber Smokefire to Traeger Ironwood pellet grills next.